Skip to content

✨ TAREA 5: Pattern Library

Status: ✅ COMPLETE Version: 1.0.0 Coverage Target: >90%

📋 Overview

Comprehensive library of 7 good architectural patterns that align with AudioLab's L0→L1→L2→L3 hierarchy and SOLID principles.

Purpose: - Detect and promote good architectural patterns - Measure architecture health (0-100 score) - Provide positive examples (inverse of anti-patterns) - Quality gates for CI/CD pipelines

✨ The 7 Good Patterns

# Pattern Type Goal
1 Layered Architecture Structural Strict L0→L1→L2→L3 hierarchy
2 Facade Structural Unified interface to subsystems
3 Dependency Inversion Dependency Depend on abstractions
4 Composition Structural Has-a over Is-a
5 Single Responsibility Behavioral One module, one purpose
6 Interface Segregation Dependency Minimal, focused interfaces
7 Acyclic Dependencies Structural No circular dependencies

🚀 Quick Start

1. Basic Usage

#include "pattern_library.hpp"

using namespace audiolab::hierarchy;

// Load modules
std::map<std::string, ModuleMetadata> modules = /* ... */;
auto graph = DependencyGraph::build_from_modules(modules);

// Get global library (auto-initialized with 7 patterns)
auto& library = global_pattern_library();

// Detect all patterns
auto instances = library.detect_all(modules, graph);

// Generate report
std::string report = library.generate_report(instances);
std::cout << report;

2. Check Architecture Health

int health = calculate_architecture_health(modules, graph);

if (health >= 75) {
    std::cout << "✅ Good architecture: " << health << "/100\n";
} else {
    std::cout << "⚠️ Needs improvement: " << health << "/100\n";
}

3. Count Excellent Patterns

size_t excellent = count_excellent_patterns(modules, graph);
std::cout << "✨ Excellent patterns: " << excellent << "\n";

📊 Pattern Detection

1. Layered Architecture (O(E))

LayeredArchitecturePattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Finds modules with clean L0→L1→L2→L3 dependencies

Example: 

L3_Synth → L2_Voice → L1_Filter → L0_Math  // ✅ Clean layering

2. Facade Pattern (O(V))

FacadePattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Finds modules coordinating 3-15 subsystems from level below

Example: 

L2_Engine (facade):
  → L1_Osc + L1_Filter + L1_Env + L1_Mixer  // ✅ Facade

3. Dependency Inversion (O(V))

DependencyInversionPattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Finds interfaces with high fan-in (multiple implementers)

Example: 

L1_IProcessor (interface)
  ← L1_FilterImpl : IProcessor  // ✅ DI
  ← L1_EffectImpl : IProcessor

4. Composition Pattern (O(V))

CompositionPattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Finds modules composing ≥2 components from level below

Example: 

L2_Voice (composes):
  → L1_Osc + L1_Filter + L1_Env  // ✅ Composition

5. Single Responsibility (O(V))

SingleResponsibilityPattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Finds modules with deps within thresholds

Thresholds (Excellent): - L0: 0 deps - L1: ≤10 deps - L2: ≤20 deps - L3: ≤30 deps

6. Interface Segregation (O(V))

InterfaceSegregationPattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Finds interfaces with ≤5 deps and ≥2 implementers

7. Acyclic Dependencies (O(V+E))

AcyclicDependenciesPattern detector;
auto instances = detector.detect(modules, graph);
// Uses Tarjan's SCC algorithm to find acyclic modules

🧪 Testing

cd build
ctest -R test_pattern_library -V

Coverage: >90%

Test Cases: 40+

📈 Quality Levels

  • ✨ EXCELLENT (95-100%): Perfect implementation
  • ✅ GOOD (80-94%): Strong implementation
  • ⚠️ ACCEPTABLE (65-79%): Present but weak
  • ❌ POOR (50-64%): Barely detectable
  • ❓ NO MATCH (<50%): Not present

🔧 Architecture Health Score

Formula: 

Health = (70% × Avg Pattern Quality) + (30% × Coverage)

Coverage = (Modules in Patterns / Total Modules) × 100

Interpretation: - 90-100: ✨ Excellent - 75-89: ✅ Good - 60-74: ⚠️ Acceptable - <60: ❌ Poor

📚 API Reference

Main Classes

ArchitecturalPattern (Abstract Base)

class ArchitecturalPattern {
public:
    virtual std::vector<PatternInstance> detect(
        const std::map<std::string, ModuleMetadata>& modules,
        const DependencyGraph& graph
    ) const = 0;
};

PatternLibrary

class PatternLibrary {
public:
    void register_default_patterns();

    std::vector<PatternInstance> detect_all(...) const;
    std::vector<PatternInstance> detect_pattern(const std::string& id, ...) const;

    std::string generate_report(...) const;
};

PatternInstance

struct PatternInstance {
    std::string pattern_id;
    std::string pattern_name;
    PatternType type;
    PatternQuality quality;
    int quality_score;  // 0-100
    std::vector<std::string> involved_modules;
    std::string description;
    std::string benefits;
    std::vector<std::string> improvements;

    std::string to_string() const;
};

Global Singleton

PatternLibrary& global_pattern_library();

Utilities

size_t count_excellent_patterns(...);
int calculate_architecture_health(...);
PatternQuality score_to_quality(int score);

🎓 Examples

Run Interactive Demo

./build/examples/pattern_demo

Scenarios: 1. Layered Architecture 2. Facade Pattern 3. Dependency Inversion 4. Single Responsibility 5. Comprehensive Health Check

📖 Documentation

🔗 Dependencies

Internal: - 05_01_00_level_definitions (TAREA 1) - 05_01_02_validation_engine (TAREA 3)

External: - C++20 compiler - Catch2 v3 (testing)

✅ Success Criteria

  • 7 patterns implemented
  • Detection algorithms complete
  • Test suite >90% coverage
  • Architecture health scoring
  • Pattern quality levels
  • Comprehensive documentation
  • Interactive demo
  • CI/CD integration examples

📊 Performance

Operation Complexity Time (500 modules)
Layered Detection O(E) <10ms
Facade Detection O(V) <5ms
DI Detection O(V) <5ms
Composition Detection O(V) <5ms
SRP Detection O(V) <5ms
ISP Detection O(V) <5ms
Acyclic Detection (Tarjan) O(V+E) ~50ms
Total Scan O(V+E) <100ms

🔌 Integration

CI/CD Quality Gate

- name: Pattern Analysis
  run: |
    health=$(./build/tools/pattern_checker --health)
    if [ $health -lt 60 ]; then
      echo "❌ Architecture health too low: $health/100"
      exit 1
    fi
    echo "✅ Architecture health: $health/100"

Pre-Commit Hook

#!/bin/bash
./build/tools/pattern_checker --min-health=75

if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then
    echo "❌ Commit rejected: Architecture health below threshold"
    exit 1
fi

🚀 Next Steps

TAREA 6: Build Order Calculator (05_01_05_build_order_calculator/) - Topological sort for module compilation - Parallel build optimization - Build time estimation

📝 Notes

Design Decisions: - Tarjan's algorithm for SCC detection (O(V+E)) - Heuristic-based interface detection (name patterns + fan-in) - Quality scoring combines multiple factors - Singleton pattern for global library

Extensibility: - Easy to add new patterns via add_pattern() - Custom scoring via inheritance - Plugin architecture for pattern detectors

Status: ✅ COMPLETE Version: 1.0.0 Last Updated: 2025-10-10